BestPractice Logo

BestPractice

LoginGet Started
AI & Mental Health

Published on February 6, 2025

AI in Mental Health – Enhancing Therapy Without Losing the Human Touch

Exploring how to use AI to support therapists and patients ethically, without replacing the human connection that’s vital for healing.

Author

Taylor Hayduk

Founder @ BestPractice, Inc.

A young therapist pores over her session notes late into the night, wishing for more hours in the day. Meanwhile, a college student, too anxious to dial a hotline, opens up to a friendly chatbot at 3 AM. Welcome to the new reality of mental health care, where artificial intelligence (AI) is stepping in as a helper and companion. AI is revolutionizing therapy—from apps that support clinicians with note-taking and scheduling, to AI “friends” that keep lonely individuals company. The big question: Can we harness these innovations without sacrificing the authentic human connection that healing relies on?

This post explores how AI is being used to support therapists and patients, the ethical safeguards and best practices needed to keep therapy human, and the controversial rise of AI companions like “AI girlfriends.” We’ll look at data, expert insights, and real cases to paint a picture of a future where tech and therapists work hand-in-hand—and how to avoid the pitfalls along the way.

AI as a Therapist’s Ally: Benefits and Use Cases

In therapy offices around the world, AI is quietly making its presence known—not as a replacement for therapists, but as a powerful assistant. Consider some of the ways AI tools are augmenting mental health practice:

  • Automating Admin and Analysis: AI can transcribe therapy sessions, flag keywords, and even analyze speech patterns for signs of distress.
  • Improving Access & Consistency: Chatbot “therapists” can be available 24/7 for check-ins and basic support.
  • Personalized Coaching: Modern AI tailors its responses based on user input, delivering a tailored experience to thousands at once.
  • Data-Driven Insights: AI systems can crunch vast datasets of therapy transcripts or journal entries, detecting patterns clinicians might miss.

Early statistics are promising. In the U.S., 50% of therapy platforms now integrate some form of AI, up from 25% just a few years ago. Therapists themselves report significant benefits: 65% of those using AI tools say it’s improved their efficiency and reduced burnout. Offloading routine tasks to an AI can free up clinicians to focus on empathy and treatment. Meanwhile, some clients prefer opening up to a non-judgmental chatbot—paradoxically, they feel it’s easier to share intimate details with an AI than a human.

Ethical Concerns: Keeping the “Human” in Human Services

With great power comes great responsibility. As soon as AI enters the therapy room, a host of ethical and practical concerns arise. Chief among them is the fear of losing the human touch that is the cornerstone of therapy. Can empathy, trust, and genuine connection survive when part of the interaction is machine-driven? Experts warn that while AI can assist, it cannot truly feel.

Beyond this fundamental limitation, there are other issues to navigate:

  • Privacy & Data Security: Therapy often involves sharing personal secrets. If that data is processed by an AI, can it be kept safe?
  • Bias & Fairness: AI learns from data, which may reflect societal biases. The result could be skewed advice or misinterpretations for certain groups.
  • Reliability & Safety: What happens if a chatbot fails to recognize a crisis situation? Human oversight remains crucial.
  • Dehumanization of Care: If health systems rely too heavily on AI, therapy risks becoming impersonal.
“The litmus test for any mental health AI should be: does this help the client, and would I trust it with my own loved one?”

The consensus is that AI and human therapists must work in tandem. Keep a clinician in the loop; use AI for admin tasks, data-crunching, and 24/7 availability. But remember: the core healing relationship remains between patient and human therapist.

When AI Becomes “Friend”: The Rise and Risks of AI Companions

Not all AI in mental health is clinical. One of the fastest-growing trends is AI companion apps—designed to be your friend, confidante, or even romantic partner. User numbers have skyrocketed, with some platforms reaching 15 million monthly users. Many young people find comfort and acceptance in these virtual friends, who are never “too busy” or judgmental.

But there are dangers. AI “friends” can foster emotional dependency; some might over-rely on a bot, neglecting real-world interactions. Experts also warn that these apps can worsen social isolation if they become a substitute for genuine human relationships. When one AI companion banned romantic role-play, some users spiraled, with therapists reporting clients experiencing intense grief.

“Falling in love with an AI is risky, because it pretends to care … but it doesn’t actually care about you.”

Are they harmless or harmful? Possibly both. Some people find temporary relief from loneliness, but others become more isolated. We’re only beginning to understand the psychological impact of AI companionship. For now, the best advice is caution and moderation.

Striking a Balance: A Future of Hybrid Healing

AI is here to stay, but it's up to us to ensure it supports—rather than supplants—true human interaction. The ideal model? A hybrid approach that pairs human empathy with ethical, well-designed technology:

Therapist + AI Collaboration: Let AI handle repetitive tasks and surface insights, while the therapist remains responsible for empathy and complex decision-making. For instance, BestPractice automates note-taking, freeing clinicians to focus on authentic human connections rather than administrative overhead.

Bridging Between Sessions: BestPractice is exploring a user-facing app that provides mood tracking, guided journaling, and self-soothing resources without turning the therapist into a 24/7 chatbot. Think of it as a low-touch digital companion—helping clients stay on track between sessions—while still ensuring the therapist's time goes where it matters most.

Promoting Human Support: Rather than mimic an AI friend, this app gently nudges users to reflect on their feelings, record daily stressors, and practice exercises that boost well-being. Meanwhile, therapists gain valuable insights, spotting trends or urgent needs without being chained to an endless chat stream. This setup complements human care, rather than replacing it.

Ultimately, we believe AI should handle the "busy work" that bogs down clinicians, so they can focus on people instead of paperwork. And while technology can provide 24/7 availability, let's never lose sight of human empathy. It's the heartbeat of therapy that no machine can replicate. With the right design, we remain anchored in privacy, ethics, and trust—using AI to empower therapists and clients, not overshadow genuine human care.

Conclusion: Embracing Innovation, Preserving Humanity

AI’s surge into mental health is both exciting and inevitable. We’re already seeing how algorithms can lift burdens off therapists and offer a lifeline to people in need at any hour. Yet we must remember: healing happens through human connection. Empathy, understanding, and trust are not optional extras; they’re the bedrock of mental health care.

The future of mental health is likely a hybrid model: a compassionate therapist augmented by intelligent tools and communities that responsibly integrate technology. If we get this right, AI won’t replace what makes therapy special. Instead, it will elevate it—combining the best of tech with the best of humanity to foster greater healing and understanding for all.

AI should support, not replace, human therapists.

Ethical safeguards are essential to protect privacy and trust.

Balance is key: harness AI's benefits while preserving humanity.

Ready to enhance your practice?

Share this article

Sources

  1. PositivePsychology.com"Revolutionizing AI Therapy: The Impact on Mental Health Care"
  2. TherapyTalk.io"AI in Mental Health Care – Global Trends and Statistics (2024)"
  3. ARK Invest"Is AI Companionship the Next Frontier...?"
  4. Psychology Today"The Dangers of AI-Generated Romance"
  5. Redditr/Replika forum, "Psychologist here."
  6. Minerva & Giubilini (2023)"The Ethics of AI in Mental Healthcare: A Systematic Review"
  7. Additional Studies